Hans kelson 18811973 introduction credit of reviving the original analytical legal thought in 20th century pure theory of law. Hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. International peace through international law danilo zolo the idea of law. Reprint of the second revised and enlarged edition, a complete revision of the first edition published in 1934. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law provides a particular approach to law and normativity. Kelsen distinguishes his pure theory of law from both traditional natural law theory and traditional legal positivism, and instead identifies his theory as a middleway between the two traditional theories. The communist theory of law by hans kelsen, 1955 online. Hanno kaiser 2004 1 law and nature law and nature are categorically di. The present paper purports to provide an analytical reconstruction and critical assessment of such a critique.
The basic norm, he says, is an accepted custom, or in kelsen s. What are the mains points of criticism of this theory. It offers a grammar and a vocabulary that helps us identify some legal concepts and problems as essential and to dismiss others as alien to the main tasks of legal scholarship. A distinguished law professor who drafted the 1920 austrian constitution, he fled nazism, eventually going to the u. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by corelating it with all social sciences and rigorously. Kelsen s contribution the credit goes to kelsen for evolving a pure theory of law. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is a positivist theory that has been enormously influential in the world of jurisprudence.
Part one surveys the fundamentals of kelsen s argumentative strategy against natural law and its theorists. The second revised and enlarged edition, being a completely revised version of the first edition which was published in 1934. Kelsen defends a monism, that is, the view that international law and the various state legal systems taken together constitute a unified normative system, and b the primacy of international. With his pure theory of law, hans kelsen did not wish to present any new ideology of law. Kelsen s book contains only text neither logical notation nor pictures. The soviet legal theory, to which the second part of this essay is devoted, is dominated almost exclusively by political factors. Thus, the legal system, for kelsen, was the primary source of law in particular, the fundamental norm. He was a professor of law at the vienna university. A communist may indeed not admit that there is an essential difference. Written during a tense period of the cold war, this study observed that bolshevism was a system that embraces.
He contributed to legal philosophy in such works as principles. Kelsen 18811973, was the author of more than forty works on law and legal philosophy, and is best known for this title and general theory of law and state. The pure theory of law positivism kelsen was a legal positivist. Kelsen s legal monismthe claim that it is impossible for legal science to recognize the existence of more than one legal systemis often held to be one of the least plausible aspects of kelsen s pure theory of law. Translation from the second german edition by max knight. Rather, his aim was to present law as it is, free from all the various ideologies. Pdf visualization of hans kelsens pure theory of law. Through his analysis, kelsen explains his own pure theory of law, inevitably comparing it with the marxist doctrines described. Gt for the general theory of law and state new york. The antinomies of evgeni pashukanis university of warwick. According to vladimir kubes8, scientific activities of h. In the first paragraph of pure theory of law, kelsen introduces his theory as being a theory of positive law. Hans kelsen on international law francois rigaux abstract kelsen s monistic theory of law, according to which international and municipal law have the same subjectmatter, paved the way for the dominant contemporary doctrine.
Reine rechtslehre is a book by legal theorist hans kelsen, first published in 1934 and in a greatly expanded second edition effectively a new book in 1960. This essay first sets out the epistemological basis of the pure theory in cognition of the law, that is, on how exactly law is perceived and recognized. Reginald parker,the communist theory of law by hans kelsen, 8 w. Hans kelsen uc press ebooks collection california digital.
International peace through international law danilo zolo the idea of law, in spite of everything, seems still to be stronger than any ideology of power. As such, it facilitates understanding of the communist theory of law. Due to the rise of totalitarianism in austria and a 1929 constitutional change, kelsen left for germany in 1930 but was. Socialism communism capitalism philosophy optional upscias duration. Hans kelsen and puretheory of law hans kelsen advocated pure theory of law. Hans kelsen, natural law doctrine and legal positivism, in general theory of the law and state. Rechtslehre or pure theory of law hereinafter kelsen, problems. Kelsen is most famous for his studies on law and especially for his idea known as the pure theory of the law. Dec 08, 2014 hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. Hart propounded that law is union of primary and secondary rules. Kelsen abstract this article focuses on hans kelsens theory of international law and pacifism.
He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960. Introduction by the time he anived in the united states in 1940, hans kelsen was already recognized as the worlds leading legal theorist. The code of the legal system, the formative distinction that creates and perpetuates the identity of the legal system is lawful. Kelsen says that it is valid,1 and validity is the mode of existence of norms.
The public international law theory of hans kelsen. Favorit book the communist theory of law hans kelsen boook online. The traditional legal philosophies at the time, were, kelsen claimed, hopelessly contaminated with. The grundnorm lies outside positive laws and norms. Kelsens theory of the basic norm joseph raz of all. It insists on a distinction between human law, which they call positive law and moral and scientific laws. The law was the law, not admitting the influence of extra legem elements in it. Kelsen did not deny the value of ethics, politics, history, sociology, etcbut his theory of law was clear of those consideration. In his pure theory of law says kelsen, that law should be kept pure from extra legal affairs. A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence, the. Kelsen wanted to avoid austins recourse to habit, but ends up facing a similar problem and giving a more complex but still inadequate solution. The second edition appeared in english translation in 1967, as pure theory of law, the first edition in english translation in 1992, as introduction to the problems of legal theory.
Hans kelsens pure theory of law in the land of the legal realists d. Kelsen have passed a development way of several decades which include four distinctly marked stages phases. Naveed hussain page 1 kelsen s pure theory of law in simple words, law may be promulgated, passed, adopted, or otherwise posited by an official or entity vested with authority by the government to prescribe the values and regulations for the community. Kelsen s critique of natural law ows from his theory of democracy and sci ence. In 1949 hans kelsen wrote a short book on the political theory of. Usually, the kind of dualism discussed is influenced by descartes who argued that a characteristic feature of matter is that it is ex. The author of this paper deals with the basic causes of numerous often. Kelsen s pure theory can be said to be one of the most refined developments of analytical positivism.
The pure theory of law is termed as theory of positive law. Their philosophy is analysis with reference to the marxist philosophy of law and state espoused by marx and engels. An observation on the theory of law of hans kelsen 553 about. The jurisprudence kelsen propounded characterizes itself as a pure theory of law because it aims at cognition focused on the law alone and this purity serves as its basic methodological principle pt1, 7.
Review of the communist theory of law by hans kelsen chicago. The austrian philosopher and jurist named han kelsen proposed the pure theory of law. Kelsens legal theory refers only to kelsens works published between the two world wars, the arguments of this criticism are neither outdated nor obsolete. October 11, 1881 april 19, 1973 was an austrian jurist, legal philosopher and political philosopher. Apr 07, 2015 kelsens contribution the credit goes to kelsen for evolving a pure theory of law.
Kelsen s pure theory is about the hierarchy of norms. Kelsen article about kelsen by the free dictionary. The transcendentalist pretension t o absolute and eternally valid norms cut against the grain of modern science. He was the author of the 1920 austrian constitution, which to a very large degree is still valid today. The aim of a theory of law is to reduce chaos and multiplicity to unity. Hans kelsen, the theory of law and the international legal system. According to kelsen, the standard legal philosophies were marred with contamination of. Kelsen abstract this article focuses on hans kelsen s theory of international law and pacifism.
Hans kelsen s pure theory of law and its doctrine of the grund norm has achieved a. Written during a tense period of the cold war, this study observed that bolshevism was a system that embraces anarchism. Kelsen defends a monism, that is, the view that international law and the various state legal systems taken together constitute a unified normative system, and b the primacy of international law over state. Kelsen writes that theory of law must be from ethics, politics, sociology, history, etcin other words it must be pure. It is pure in distinguishing the law from sociology and in distinguishing it from morality. Kelsen started his pure theory with certain premises. The positivity of law, in his words, lies in the fact that it is created and annulled by acts of human beings, thus. During the 1950s, kelsen wrote several works devoted to the marxist theory of law, in which socialist legal theory and practice are examined from a position of active anticommunism. The is grundnorm the reason for the validity of the constitution as seen by legal science. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by co.
Pdf radomir lukics introduction to law was a model textbook in. Ebenstein, chapter 1, is an excellent discussion of the kantian basis of kelsen s thought. Big deals the public international law theory of hans kelsen. He has separated jurisprudence from all other social science and liberated the flaw from the metaphysical must with which it has been covered at all times by speculations of justice or by the doctrine of exponent of the viennese jus natural his views on law are contained in his book entitled general theory of. Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthy. A critical analysis of the communist theory of law seems to the author of this essay to be of value not only to scientific jurisprudence but for the abovementioned reasons to social science in general. Kelsens book contains only text neither logical notation nor pictures. The soviet legal theory, to which the second part of this essay is devoted, is. In a series of essays published from the late 1920s up to the mid1960s, hans kelsen carried out a radical critique of natural law theory. Hans kelsens pure theory of law by tim murphy ssrn. The pure theory of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the formidable austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen 18811973 see the bibliographical note. From an intrasystemic, internal, or legal point of view, law is norm, not fact. Human laws are posits of human society while scientific laws are independent of what we take them to be.
The communist theory of law, stevens and sons, 1955. Hart, and many other legal theorists for legal normative systems kelsen called the basic norm grundnorm oing ssay his on orget utline elsen heory irst articularly he ature. Kelsen gives a good description of marxs philosophy of natural law, a topic inadequately covered by other sources, and how it. Kelsen sopure theory of law, comment on his view of customary courtmade law, and briefly critique his concept of the basic norm. The court decision is a continuation, not the beginning, of the legal creation process kelsen, pure theory of law at p.
Marx, law, ideology, legal positivism chicago unbound. I recall only that at the paris meeting kelsen showed he appreciated the arguments in my report on natural law. Instead, kelsen suggested a pure theory of law which would avoid reductionism of any kind. The remainder of the norms are associated by inferior norms, when one is contrasted with another 4. Law as the primary source of law the court decision is a continuation, not the beginning, of the legal creation process kelsen, pure theory of law at p. Jan 29, 20 kelsens pure theory is about the hierarchy of norms.
Kelsen s pure theory of law 1 law is a normative science according to kelsen law is a normative science but law norms of science are norms of is sein means law norms may be distinguished from science norms on the ground that norms of science are norms. As kant is followed by hegel, neokantians, including kelsen, are followed by hegelian dialectics. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. He was also the author of the austrian democratic constitution, which was published in 1920, abolished during the nazi regime, restored in 1945, and in force today. Kelsen began his long career as a legal theorist at the beginning of the 20th century. This paper challenges the criticism of kelsen s monism in. How can they explain the legitimacy of the rule of law itselfof the basic norm of law. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. Hans kelsens pure theory of law provides a particular approach to law and normativity. A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence, the pure theory of law defines law as a system of coercive norms created by the state that rests on the validity of a generally accepted grundnorm, or basic norm, such as the supremacy of the constitution. Hence, the theory is more so given in terms of formation of hierarchical laws commencing from basic norm. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960 the theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. Kelsen s argument in the form of a kantian transcendental argument 1 p is possible only if q 2 p is possible or, possibly p 3 therefore, q p the fact that legal norms are ought statements q pressuposition of the basic norm 12.
Rechtslehre the pure theory of law3 given by one of kelsens greatest disciples. Kelsen summarizes the philosophy of law and state of the most prominent soviet legal philosophers, such as stuchka, reisner, pashukanis, vyshinsky, golunskii, and strogovich. Hans kelsen was a european legal philosopher and teacher who emigrated to the united states in 1940 after leaving nazi germany. In kelsens theory, however, there is a sharp distinction between the two. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law is a positivist theory that has been enormously influential in the world of jurisprudence. He also says about the normative behaviour which takes validity from the ground norm. Case western reserve university school of law scholarly commons year. The theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics. May 19, 2016 hans kelsen and puretheory of law hans kelsen advocated pure theory of law. This theory of positive law is then presented by kelsen as forming a hierarchy of laws which start from a basic norm grundnorm where all other norms are related to each other by either being inferior norms, when the one is compared to the other, or. Or kelson wishes to free the law from the metaphysical mist which it has been covered of all times. In spite of everything, seems still to be stronger than any ideology of power.
908 541 1425 1343 338 1336 653 999 1352 371 764 594 788 1387 462 487 874 763 444 279 725 1526 1218 466 839 1217 330 1191 197 29 672 1340 987 195 1298 198 1063 83 597 560 1087 472 459 1499 246 55